Deshaun Watson, once hailed as one of the NFL’s brightest quarterback prospects, has been at the center of intense scrutiny due to his unprecedented contract with the Cleveland Browns. Signed in 2022 after a blockbuster trade from the Houston Texans, Watson’s five-year, $230 million fully guaranteed deal set a new benchmark in NFL contracts. However, the contract’s implications, coupled with Watson’s on-field performance, injuries, and off-field controversies, have sparked widespread debate.
This article dives deep into the details of Watson’s contract, its recent restructurings, financial impacts, and the questions fans and analysts are asking on platforms like Google and YouTube. Drawing from the latest available information, we aim to provide a thorough and engaging exploration of this polarizing topic.
Background: The Trade and the Record-Breaking Contract
In March 2022, the Cleveland Browns acquired Deshaun Watson from the Houston Texans in a trade that sent shockwaves through the NFL. The trade package included three first-round draft picks, a third-round pick, and two fourth-round picks, reflecting the high value placed on Watson’s potential. Immediately after the trade, the Browns signed Watson to a five-year, $230 million contract, fully guaranteed an unprecedented move in a league where guaranteed money is typically reserved for only the most elite players. This deal, with an average annual value (AAV) of $46 million, made Watson one of the highest-paid quarterbacks in the NFL at the time.
The contract’s fully guaranteed nature was particularly notable. Unlike most NFL contracts, which include non-guaranteed portions subject to performance or roster status, Watson’s deal ensured he would receive the entire $230 million regardless of his performance, health, or off-field issues. This structure was a departure from NFL norms and set a new precedent, raising questions about its long-term implications for the Browns and the league. The deal included a $44.965 million signing bonus, with the remaining amount spread across base salaries and roster bonuses over the five years.
At the time, Watson was coming off a two-year period of limited play. He sat out the entire 2021 season with the Texans due to a trade demand and faced significant off-field challenges, including over 20 civil lawsuits alleging sexual misconduct during massage sessions. Despite these uncertainties, the Browns bet big on Watson, banking on his proven talent from his 2017–2020 tenure with Houston, where he earned three Pro Bowl selections and led the league in passing yards in 2020.
Recent Restructurings: Managing the Cap Burden
The Browns have restructured Watson’s contract multiple times to alleviate salary cap constraints. In December 2024, the team adjusted the deal to ease future cap burdens, though specific details of this restructuring were not fully disclosed. On March 6, 2025, the Browns announced another restructuring, creating approximately $35.8–$36 million in cap space for the 2025 season. This move reduced Watson’s 2025 cap hit from $73 million, though he is still set to receive $46 million in cash for the year.
Restructuring typically involves converting portions of a player’s base salary into signing bonuses, which are then prorated over the remaining years of the contract. This spreads the cap hit more evenly but extends the financial commitment, potentially increasing dead cap space if the player is released. For Watson, these restructurings have kept the Browns cap-compliant but have not erased the long-term financial weight of the deal. The team was reportedly $22 million over the cap before the March 2025 restructuring, underscoring the necessity of these adjustments.
Insurance and Injury Considerations
Watson’s contract includes an insurance policy that has become a focal point of discussion, particularly after his season-ending Achilles injury in 2024. According to reports, up to $44.2 million of Watson’s 2025 salary is insured, potentially allowing the Browns to recoup a significant portion of his compensation if he is unable to play due to injury. Additionally, the Browns could recover half of Watson’s 2024 salary for the games missed due to injury, plus the entirety of his 2025 compensation if he remains sidelined.
This insurance clause provides some financial protection, but it doesn’t fully mitigate the contract’s burden. The Browns remain on the hook for $92 million in guaranteed money over the final two years (2025–2026), regardless of Watson’s playing status. The insurance aspect has fueled speculation about whether the Browns might attempt to void portions of the contract or seek further financial relief, though such moves are complicated by the fully guaranteed structure.
Performance vs. Contract Value
Watson’s on-field performance since joining the Browns has been a lightning rod for criticism. After sitting out 2021 and serving an 11-game suspension in 2022 due to the NFL’s personal conduct policy, Watson has played only 19 games over three seasons (2022–2024). His 2024 season ended prematurely due to a torn Achilles, further limiting his impact. In those 19 games, Watson has posted modest stats: 2,974 passing yards, 15 touchdowns, and 11 interceptions, a far cry from his Pro Bowl-caliber numbers in Houston.
Critics argue that the contract’s value is disproportionate to Watson’s output. A post on X bluntly stated, “‘Deshaun Watson is the worst contract in NFL history. He simply can’t play the game anymore,’” accompanied by a video highlighting his struggles with deep passes in 2024. The Browns’ decision to acquire four new quarterbacks in the 2025 offseason further underscores doubts about Watson’s role as the team’s franchise quarterback.
However, some defend the contract, noting that Watson’s talent was undeniable before his legal and injury issues. One X user argued that the $46 million AAV looks reasonable compared to newer quarterback contracts, which have pushed the market higher. For context, recent deals for quarterbacks like Joe Burrow ($55 million AAV) and Trevor Lawrence ($55 million AAV) have surpassed Watson’s, though none are fully guaranteed.
Off-Field Controversies and Contract Implications
Watson’s off-field issues have been inseparable from discussions about his contract. The 2022 trade and signing came amid over 20 civil lawsuits alleging sexual misconduct, most of which have since been settled. However, a new lawsuit emerged in 2024, prompting further scrutiny. The NFL suspended Watson for 11 games in 2022, and the Browns structured his contract to minimize financial impact during the suspension, with a low base salary for that year.
The controversies have fueled ethical debates about the Browns’ decision to offer such a lucrative deal. One X post contrasted Watson’s contract with the release of kicker Justin Tucker by the Ravens for similar allegations, highlighting perceived inconsistencies in how teams handle such issues. Fans and analysts frequently ask whether the Browns can void the contract due to off-field issues, but the fully guaranteed nature makes this unlikely without mutual agreement or extraordinary circumstances.
Financial Implications for the Browns
The Watson contract has significant ramifications for the Browns’ roster construction and financial flexibility. The team’s cap situation was dire entering the 2025 offseason, with reports indicating they were $22 million over the cap before the March restructuring. The $36 million in cap space created by the restructuring provides breathing room, but the Browns still face challenges in 2026, when Watson’s cap hit could again balloon.
The fully guaranteed structure limits the Browns’ options. Releasing Watson would result in massive dead cap hits potentially over $100 million making it financially impractical. Trading him is equally challenging, as any acquiring team would need to absorb the remaining guaranteed money. The insurance policy offers some relief, but it’s not a complete solution.
The Browns’ aggressive pursuit of other quarterbacks in 2025 suggests they are hedging their bets. Posts on X note that the team’s acquisition of four new quarterbacks signals a lack of confidence in Watson’s ability to return to form, especially post-injury. This move, while prudent, further complicates the financial picture, as the team must allocate resources to multiple quarterback contracts.
Comparisons to Other NFL Contracts
Watson’s deal is often compared to other high-profile quarterback contracts to assess its value. When signed in 2022, the $46 million AAV was among the highest in the league. However, the quarterback market has since exploded, with players like Burrow, Lawrence, and Tua Tagovailoa securing deals above $50 million AAV. Unlike Watson’s contract, these deals include partial guarantees, giving teams more flexibility.
The fully guaranteed nature of Watson’s contract remains its defining feature. Only a handful of NFL players, such as Kirk Cousins (with the Vikings in 2018), have received fully guaranteed deals, but none match Watson’s scale. Critics argue that the Browns’ decision disrupted the quarterback market, forcing other teams to offer larger guarantees to compete. An X user noted, “‘The QB market has been busted ever since the Browns screwed the pooch with that Watson contract.’”
Future Outlook: Can the Browns Move On?
One of the most common questions on Google and YouTube is whether the Browns can escape Watson’s contract. The short answer is: not easily. The fully guaranteed structure means the Browns are committed to paying Watson $92 million over 2025 2026, whether he plays or not. Releasing him would trigger crippling dead cap hits, and trading him requires a willing partner to absorb the remaining guarantees, a tall order given Watson’s recent performance and injury history.
The Achilles injury adds further uncertainty. Recovery from a torn Achilles typically takes 9–12 months, and there’s no guarantee Watson will regain his pre-injury form. The Browns’ insurance policy may offset some costs, but it doesn’t solve the long-term problem.
Analysts speculate that the Browns could explore creative solutions, such as a post-June 1 release in 2026 to spread the dead cap hit over multiple years. However, this would still leave the team with significant financial constraints. Alternatively, if Watson returns to elite form, the contract could be seen as a bargain in a rising quarterback market. This scenario, however, seems optimistic given current sentiment, as reflected in posts calling the contract a “‘quarter billion dollar’” mistake.
Fan Sentiment and Media Coverage
Sentiment around Watson’s contract is overwhelmingly negative, as evidenced by posts on X and YouTube comments. Fans frequently label it the “‘worst contract in NFL history,’” citing Watson’s limited play, injuries, and off-field issues. Media coverage echoes this, with outlets like ESPN and NFL.com questioning whether Watson has a future in Cleveland or the NFL.
However, some fans argue that the Browns had little choice but to offer a massive deal to secure a quarterback of Watson’s caliber, especially given competition from other teams during the 2022 trade talks. The restructuring efforts also suggest the Browns are committed to making the deal work, at least for now.
YouTube videos analyzing the contract often focus on its financial mechanics, with titles like “How Deshaun Watson’s Contract Broke the NFL” or “Why the Browns Can’t Escape Watson’s Deal.” These videos break down cap hits, dead money, and restructuring options, catering to fans seeking detailed explanations. The popularity of such content underscores the public’s fascination with the contract’s scale and consequences.
FAQs
How has Watson performed since joining the Browns?
Since joining the Browns in 2022, Watson has played in 19 games over three seasons. During this time, he has faced injuries and legal issues, impacting his on-field performance. In 2024, he suffered a season-ending Achilles injury, and the team struggled with a 1–6 record in games he started .
What are the Browns’ options regarding Watson’s future?
The Browns are exploring their options for the 2026 season and beyond. With a significant dead cap hit if they release Watson, they are considering restructuring his contract further or potentially moving on from him in the near future .
How does Watson’s contract compare to other top NFL quarterbacks?
Watson’s contract ranks among the highest in NFL history, comparable to deals signed by Patrick Mahomes, Josh Allen, and Aaron Rodgers. The high guaranteed money and length of the contract highlight the Browns’ confidence in Watson’s abilities and leadership.
What impact does Watson’s contract have on the Cleveland Browns’ salary cap?
Watson’s contract is structured to help manage the Browns’ salary cap with signing bonuses spread over the contract term and roster bonuses timed to give the team flexibility. This approach helps the Browns balance building a competitive roster around Watson.
Has Watson’s contract been affected by any off-field issues or suspensions?
Watson faced legal challenges and a suspension during his early career with Houston, which impacted his playing time and market value. However, his contract with the Browns reflects a fresh start and strong belief in his talent and professionalism.
In Summary
Deshaun Watson’s $230 million fully guaranteed contract remains one of the most polarizing deals in NFL history. Its unprecedented structure, combined with Watson’s limited play, injuries, and off-field controversies, has made it a lightning rod for criticism. The Browns’ repeated restructurings have provided short-term cap relief, but the long-term financial burden persists, with $92 million still owed over the next two years. The insurance policy offers some protection, but it’s not a cure-all.
Fans and analysts continue to debate the contract’s value, with Google and YouTube searches reflecting a mix of curiosity, frustration, and skepticism. While some see the deal as a bold bet on a once-elite quarterback, others view it as a cautionary tale of overcommitting to a player with significant risks. As the Browns navigate the 2025 season and beyond, Watson’s contract will remain a defining storyline, shaping the team’s roster, finances, and reputation.
To read more, Click Here .
