Blog

The Impact and Evolution of Rotten Tomatoes in Film Criticism

Rotten Tomatoes has become an essential player in the entertainment industry, bridging film enthusiasts, critics, and audiences with its influential scoring system, known as the “Tomatometer.” With its beginnings in 1998, the platform was established as a convenient way to aggregate movie reviews and categorize films based on general critical consensus. Over time, Rotten Tomatoes has grown into a cultural force and even a deciding factor for potential box office success.

How Do Rotten Tomatoes Operate and What Is It?

Rotten Tomatoes was originally conceived by Senh Duong as a site to archive all available film reviews from notable critics and media outlets, summarizing them into a single “Tomatometer” score. Films with a majority of positive reviews are marked as “Fresh,” while those with mostly negative reviews are considered “Rotten.” Rotten Tomatoes calculates the Tomatometer score as the percentage of positive reviews and ranks them based on how strongly critics either endorse or disapprove of the movie. The site also introduced an “Audience Score,” reflecting viewer reactions, creating a dual ranking that highlights discrepancies between critical and popular opinion.

Evolution of Rotten Tomatoes’ Scoring System

While Rotten Tomatoes was initially a niche service, its influence skyrocketed in the 2010s with the proliferation of social media and review platforms. Major studios began monitoring Tomatometer scores closely, as these scores increasingly swayed audience turnout. Notably, a high score on Rotten Tomatoes can boost ticket sales, while a low score has been known to reduce a film’s box office potential.

The introduction of more refined categories like “Certified Fresh” for movies with a score above 75% (and meeting specific critic criteria) has helped solidify Rotten Tomatoes as a trusted source. This label, coveted by filmmakers, indicates not just positive reviews but a high level of acclaim from professional critics.

2024 has seen an impressive lineup of films with various genres topping Rotten Tomatoes’ audience and critic lists. Among them are horror thrillers and much-anticipated sequels. Films like The Devil’s Bath (90% score) showcase how horror continues to be a genre that thrives on critical approval for its storytelling innovations. Similarly, A Quiet Place: Day One (87% score) has captured critical acclaim due to its unique perspective on the original storyline. Other popular titles include Venom: The Last Dance and Gladiator II, two major releases that fans are eagerly awaiting, with high expectations for their Tomatometer scores to reflect their presumed quality.

Rotten Tomatoes’ Role in the Streaming Era

With the rise of streaming services, Rotten Tomatoes has also adapted by featuring and reviewing exclusive streaming content, from Netflix originals to Prime Video blockbusters. This shift has been crucial, as a significant amount of new content is now released directly to streaming platforms, bypassing traditional theaters.

For instance, series like The Fall of the House of Usher on Netflix have gathered massive attention on Rotten Tomatoes, giving audiences immediate insight into the show’s quality without waiting for traditional release platforms. The same goes for international releases and indie productions that rely on Rotten Tomatoes’ exposure to gain a global audience.

Audience Influence and Backlash

One of Rotten Tomatoes’ unique features is its separation of critic and audience ratings. This distinction has revealed noticeable divides in opinion, especially for films with niche or controversial themes. For example, audience ratings often differ sharply from critical scores on politically charged films or movies from genres like fantasy and science fiction. These divergences are often sources of heated debate, showing that Rotten Tomatoes plays an influential role in public opinion.

However, the site has faced criticism for potentially swaying public opinion too heavily. Some argue that audiences might avoid or flock to movies based solely on their Tomatometer scores, which some filmmakers claim may negatively impact creative freedom. Additionally, Rotten Tomatoes has implemented policies to prevent review-bombing, where users intentionally lower scores due to disagreements unrelated to the actual quality of the content.

Rotten Tomatoes and Its Cultural Impact

In 2024, Rotten Tomatoes continues to shape the way audiences discover and consume movies, setting trends in film criticism and even impacting the types of projects studios choose to green-light. This platform not only provides insights for moviegoers but also gives studios and filmmakers valuable feedback on what works and what doesn’t in the eyes of both critics and general audiences.

As Rotten Tomatoes expands into new areas of content, such as more international cinema and broader streaming service coverage, its role in the industry becomes more pronounced. Whether helping audiences choose their next movie or reflecting industry shifts, Rotten Tomatoes remains a powerful player in film culture.

With an increasing influence on both Hollywood’s output and public reception, Rotten Tomatoes is likely to continue being a crucial benchmark for the quality of film and TV content, navigating the interests of audiences and the critiques of professionals in an ever-evolving media landscape.

FAQs

What is Rotten Tomatoes?

Rotten Tomatoes is a website that aggregates movie and TV show reviews from critics and audiences, providing a unique “Tomatometer” score that helps users gauge general reception. Founded in 1998, it was later acquired by Fandango in 2016, although it operates independently. The platform is known for its distinctive scoring system, which categorizes reviews as “Fresh” (positive) or “Rotten” (negative), allowing users to quickly assess a film’s popularity and critical reception.

How does the Tomatometer work?

The Tomatometer score is calculated by analyzing the percentage of positive reviews from approved critics. Movies and shows that score 60% or higher are classified as “Fresh,” while those below that threshold are labeled “Rotten.” A higher Tomatometer score often signals broader critical approval, though scores vary based on genre, critic preferences, and individual movie appeal.

What is a “Certified Fresh” rating?

Certified Fresh is a special distinction given to movies or shows that have consistently high ratings. For wide-release movies, a minimum of 80 reviews, including those from top critics, must yield a 75% or higher score to achieve this status. For limited releases, at least 40 reviews are required. This title is reviewed periodically and can be revoked if a movie’s rating drops significantly.

Can I become a Rotten Tomatoes reviewer?

Currently, Rotten Tomatoes does not accept new critic applications directly. The platform selects critics from established publications, online platforms, and notable review sites. To qualify as a Tomatometer-approved critic, applicants must have a consistent history of reviews, substantial readership, and meet various criteria that underscore credibility and influence.

In Summary

Rotten Tomatoes has evolved from a simple review aggregator to a powerful cultural force, influencing moviegoers, filmmakers, and even the types of projects studios prioritize. By offering both critic and audience scores, Rotten Tomatoes allows for a unique insight into the diverse opinions within the film-watching community. This dual perspective not only helps audiences make informed choices but also shapes industry trends and public discourse around movies and series, especially in the age of streaming.

Despite some controversies over its influence and potential impact on creative expression, Rotten Tomatoes continues to be a trusted benchmark in the entertainment industry. Its adaptability to new viewing habits, like streaming exclusives and indie films, along with its role in spotlighting international content, underscores its relevance today. As Rotten Tomatoes expands and adapts to changing audience preferences, it remains a significant tool in the world of film and television, where quality and audience appeal are constantly evolving.

To read more, Click Here .

LEAVE A RESPONSE

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *